It’s spring, and the cherry blossoms are in full bloom in Japan, the “Land of the Rising Sun” and home to the Japanese Yen. While many view spring as a time for new beginnings, from a more practical and economical perspective, it’s also means a new fiscal year in Japan, thus this is an ideal time to review all the data and attempt to gauge the Yen’s next trajectory. Of course, many want to know if the Japanese currency is facing yet another meltdown. While it is a rather straightforward question, with a seemingly straightforward answer, the fact is we must delve deep into complex issues including the mechanics of Quantitative Easing, Japan’s public debt and inflation.
What QE Does?
The intention of Quantitative Easing, or QE as it’s popularly called in the mainstream, is simply to allocate funds to the private sector which, hopefully, will revive growth and inflation. QE is based on one of the key pillars of capitalism, namely that funds are better off in the hands of the private sector if the preservation of growth is the goal. That sounds reasonable, but there is a macroeconomic issue at play, as well. Most of the time, the government (naturally, depending on which government) is deemed a vastly superior borrower to any private company or corporation; this is due, in part, to the fact that the government can print money, in the event of an emergency, to pay off its debt. This means that on a macro scale, when there is a choice, the big money will always be invested in government debt first and, then, whatever is left is allocated as credit to the private sector. Usually, this is not a problem since government debt is generally much smaller than the total outstanding debt of the private sector and therefore, there are generally plenty of funds invested as credit for the private sector. But, when there is an economic crisis, such as the one we had in America in 2007-2008 then investors will only buy government debt (i.e. bonds and notes) and if government debt is too big compared to private sector debt then there is not enough credit for the private sector. What QE does, essentially, is remove government bonds as an option from the free market so that investors will have no choice but to lend money to the private sector. Of course, investors in this case means financial institutions such as banks that provide credit to businesses, or institutions that buy corporate bonds or even private investors who buy notes or any other debt instrument from the private sector. What is important is that QE is designed specifically to compel investors to invest in the private sector. In general, QE is an effective tool for most central banks.
Now that you understand a bit more about QE and the rationale for it, it’s time to examine Japan’s problem and why its QE is, essentially, ineffective. As seen in the estimates below, the net debt of the US government is much smaller than the outstanding debt of the private sector with 78.06% of GDP vs 192.3% of GDP, thus there is plenty of liquidity left over for the private sector. But when examining the same ratios in Japan, the results are atypical; Japan’s net public debt, at 153.9% of GDP, is almost as large as net borrowings to the private sector, which itself is 188.3% of Japan’s GDP. This means that a substantial portion is allocated into the government rather than the private sector which explains Japan’s constant tendency toward deflation. In other words, Japan’s sovereign debt is just so big that it sucks the liquidity from the private sector. This is why inflation in Japan, despite the BOJ’s efforts, is not being generated, and in reality is set to fall back to zero if we neutralize Japan’s sales tax increase.
Chart courtesy of Netdania.com
Is the BOJ doing enough?
On the face of it, the Bank of Japan’s QE is considered aggressive at roughly $700 billion (of course, Yen equivalent) a year in liquidity. That may seem an awful lot but in reality it’s not because while the BOJ has increased its annual balance sheet by nearly $700 billion, Japan’s sovereign debt is poised to rise by $812 billion. This means that, at the moment, the BOJ’s current QE program would not lead to an increase in the total liquidity made available for the private sector; rather, it merely preserves the status quo. Simply stated, the BOJ is not doing enough.
What This Means for the Yen
The risk that Japanese inflation will slide back into negative territory is still running high and that means that the BOJ might find itself forced to increase its QE program even more to tackle deflation and to make any meaningful impact. However, since QE is already the subject of numerous heated debates in Japan, BOJ Governor Kuroda might decide to wait a bit longer this time before reacting. The result? The Yen is still set to weaken much further but short term volatility could emerge. If we narrow it down to numbers, the monthly USD/JPY chart indicates that the next long-term target for a bullish cycle seems to be 135, while also indicating medium term support for the pair is around 115. This means that unless there is a global crisis that causes an uptick in safe haven demand, the fundamentals suggest that the Yen’s meltdown is still far from over and could eventually take us all the way to 135, with possible corrections along the way.
Chart courtesy of Netdania.com
Look for my post next week.
INO.com Contributor - Forex
Disclosure: This article is the opinion of the contributor themselves. The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. This contributor is not receiving compensation (other than from INO.com) for their opinion.