Watching Zillow (ZG) move from over $200 per share to recent levels below $90, reflecting a more than 55% collapse in price, while the housing market continues to rally may be an indication that traders/investors have already discounted the future peak in the U.S. capital markets and Real Estate assets related to the current market environment. Zillow is not the only symbol experiencing this broad price decline. Redfin (RDFN) has also declined more than 54% over the past 7+ months.
Is the peak in real estate flippers prices sending a strong warning for traders/investors?
The peak in these stocks happened near February 16-22, 2021. This date, interestingly enough, aligns with a peak in global capital markets using my proprietary Smart Cash Index and a very clear peak in the Chinese Hang Seng Index.
Recent news that Zillow halted the purchases of homes using its "Zestimate" and Ibuyer programs, which act as a purchase, renovate, flip-type of market service allowing home sellers to get an almost instant purchase offer from Zillow has raised questions in my mind related to the potential risks involved in owning large quantities of real estate assets in a shifting market.
This news article suggests Zillow has over 2800 US homes available for sale. We are not aware of how many homes have been purchased and are waiting for completed repairs/inspections before they go on the market, but Zillow sold 5,337 homes in 2020, up from 4,313 in 2019.
This article also suggests other flipping companies are still actively engaging in this risky activity. Opendoor peaked at share price near the same February dates this year but has continued to acquire and flip more homes than Zillow over the past 5+ years. Redfin, yet another flipper company, also continues to engage in buying, renovating, and flipping real estate in hot U.S. markets.
My thinking is the rally in Real Estate prices, in some cases, more than 35%, which started near the end of 2020 and carried into the first two quarters of 2021, may have prompted a very risky race to acquire and flip hot market real estate at a time when labor shortages and commodity price rallies pushed the costs of "flipping" even higher may have put extended pressures on these firms to "flip for profits."
Then add into this mix the Chinese/Asian Real Estate market concerns and the potential that Chinese/foreign market buyers may have moved away from the super-heated U.S. Real Estate market recently while U.S. consumers are starting waiting for the U.S. Fed to potentially raise interest rates and we have a very interesting storm on the horizon.
These Flipper firms are holding large quantities of Real Estate assets where their purchase price likely reflects the dramatic increases in selling prices over the past 15+ months and is further complicated by supply-side costs for raw materials, labor, and equipment to complete the refurnished property while consumers may be starting to shift away from the "buy it at any cost" type of mentality.
Could the collapse in Zillow, Redfin, and OpenDoor reflect the underlying risks of an overly aggressive buying/flipping algorithm event?
Zillow's daily chart clearly reflects investor sentiment compared to U.S. major indexes.
This Daily Zillow Group chart clearly shows the extended price decline that has taken place over the past 7+ months. What is interesting is that the U.S. major indexes continue to push higher, and Real Estate prices continue to push higher while traders/investors are obviously not sharing the same bullish enthusiasm in Zillow, Redfin, and Opendoor.
A price collapse of over 50% is a big downside price trend for these types of companies. Consider the fact that they are buying thousands of homes across the U.S., which likely suggests they are taking on close to a $500m to $1b+ in assets/risk while attempting to quickly flip these properties for moderate profits. In a hot Real Estate market with strong buyer activity, one would think owning these hot assets would push traders/investors to believe "future profits are almost certain." Yet, that is clearly not the case on this chart.
Could it be that traders/investors are more keenly aware of the extended risks related to a potential U.S./global housing market bubble and the underlying liabilities related to a more extended downturn in this sector? Obviously, traders/investors have not been super excited about future potential profits for these firms recently. Maybe something will change in the near future? If not, this downward price trend suggests traders believe the risks outweigh the potential gains.
This Weekly Zillow chart shows how quickly the price trend reversed direction in February 2021. Remember, this date also aligned with a peak in the Chinese Hang Seng Index and likely represented a broad shift in investor sentiment as dynamics suddenly changed in the global Real Estate sector.
Still, the price of Zillow Group shares is trading near $90 – more than 400% higher than the COVID low price levels and more than 200% more than the pre-COVID average price level.
Are these price declines a warning that the Real Estate market/sector has shifted away from the active "flipper" mode and transitioned into more conservative expectations?
In Part II of this article, I'll explore more detailed market analysis and trends related to the Real Estate market and price dynamics.
After these extended downtrends in price levels for these Real Estate/Flipper firms, it seems likely that some type of base/bottom will likely set up, which may prompt a new rally phase or a breakdown below this base/bottom level. I believe these trends reflect broad market concerns related to the super-heated Real Estate market over the past 15+ months. In short, I believe this extended price decline highlights inherent risks related to the type of investments and potential returns on those investments. Traders should cautiously watch how this trend plays out over the next few months.
You don't have to be smart to make money in the stock market; you just need to think differently. That means: we do not equate an "up" market with a "good" market and vi versa – all markets present opportunities to make money!
We believe you can always take what the market gives you and make CONSISTENT money.
Learn more by visiting The Technical Traders!
Technical Traders Ltd.
Disclosure: This article is the opinion of the contributor themselves. The above is a matter of opinion provided for general information purposes only and is not intended as investment advice. This contributor is not receiving compensation for their opinion.