This Pioneering Chart Pattern Is Still One Of The Best

By: Amber Hestla, Michael J. Carr

The head-and-shoulders (HS) top is one of the best-known patterns in technical analysis. This pattern was first written about in 1930 by a financial editor at Forbes magazine who described how the HS forms and how it can be traded.

Many readers are familiar with the HS pattern. On a price chart, there will be three peaks in price at the end of the uptrend, with the center peak (the head) being higher than the other two. The peaks on the sides (the shoulders) should be about equal in height.

Connecting the bottom of the peaks gives us the neckline, and breaking the neckline is the sell signal. Real HS patterns rarely resemble the precise line diagrams seen in books, and the chart below shows one that occurred in real market conditions. The shoulders are nearly, but not quite, the same height.

The problem with charts is that their interpretation is subjective. Many traders find an HS in almost every chart they look at because some traders tend to see whatever they want to see.

Because traders see what they want to see, results vary. Some may find success looking at charts while others will suffer losses.

Using software, we can develop a precise definition of the pattern that avoids the inconsistency of less rigorous approaches. This definition can become complex.

For example, an MIT professor explained that an HS pattern is a date series in which "the magnitudes and decay pattern of the first 12 auto-correlations and the statistical significance of the Box-Pierce Q-statistic suggest the presence of a high-frequency predictable component in stock returns."

This definition isn't practical for most traders to use because most of us don't know what all those words mean. However, by using definitions like that, objective studies can be done to determine if the pattern works.

The first study on the HS pattern was done by economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. The researchers wrote:

"Though such visual, nonlinear chart patterns are applied frequently by technical analysts, our paper is one of the first to evaluate the predictive power of such patterns... We identify head-and-shoulders patterns using an objective, computer-implemented algorithm."

The results show "profits would have been both statistically and economically significant."

Studies like this show us that old ideas can be valuable in the market when those ideas are defined precisely and followed with a disciplined approach.

Another old idea in the markets is to buy stocks that go up. During the Great Depression, the entertainer Will Rogers supposedly said: "The way to make money in the stock market is to buy a stock.

Then, when it goes up, sell it. If it's not going to go up, don't buy it!"

Rogers was being funny, but we have found similar advice in other books and realized that we can actually follow that advice. Relative strength (RS) is a tool that allows us to find stocks that are going up.

The way to make money is to buy stocks with high RS and sell them when the RS turns down. RS can be precisely defined, programmed and tested. It can also be applied in real time to make buy and sell decisions.

Using this indicator, you could have captured a large gain in Best Buy (NYSE: BBY), one of the biggest winners among stocks in the SP 500 Index in 2013.

In this case, the buy signal would be given after the stock starts moving up and the sell signal comes after the decline stalls.

We have found that successful trades like this can be found by using a disciplined approach to trading. The HS pattern can be traded using only charts, but many traders would be better served by defining the pattern in a software package to help avoid buying and selling based on what they think they see.

The same is true for any trading tool. Some of the best ideas for traders have worked for decades. Those tools can now be applied consistently and objectively with automated processes that should increase profits.

This article was originally published at Pattern May Be Old, but It Still Works

Could You Really Collect $55,000 a Year in Retirement?
Now it's possible thanks to "Retirement Savings Stocks." These high-yielders dish out enough income for you to golf every day... go to Hawaii four times a year... and still have more than enough left over to fund your children's or grandchildren's education. To learn about these exclusive retirement stocks, click here.

7 thoughts on “This Pioneering Chart Pattern Is Still One Of The Best

  1. Thank you, Rusty. That's my point. That'why I referred to Tom Bulkowski, and that why I my analysis showing justification for a leg in an inverted H&S formation. Mr. Bulkowski's metres account for about a 66% success rate, and if I remember correctly, he rates it as of of the strongest and most reliable of all. Still, what is a Head and Shoulders set up? Certainly volume, previous direction, neckline slope are all in the mix. Being s Headhunter by trade, I cross reference sources. You could bookmark Investopedia's Chart Advisor and it probably wouldn't hurt your game.

    Good at ya!

    Gary Blazek

    1. I would like to apologize for the misspells on my last comment-I was running maintenance on my workstation and responded with my Droid,,,and unfortunately am suffering from "Texter's Thumb."

  2. Schabaker (mentor of Edwards & Magee) found that nearly 60% of H&S patterns abort and become continuation patterns.

    1. Any original thoughts? Forget Bulkowski if you want-you give up Schabaker and what do you have to offer? We'll see, eh? Maybe I'm wrong-I'm not in the guarantee business.

    2. Which, of course, raises the question of just how did they define a "head-and-shoulders pattern".

  3. I agree this looks like a Head and Shoulders pattern, but I can also make the case that an inverse Head and Shoulder pattern is forming with mid Sep to Mid Oct being the left shoulder,,, AND, there is strong horizontal support/resistance line going back through the beginning of 2013, which is now support, AND the DXY broke a strong diagonal resistance line which is also support AND DXY is now at the bottom of a very tighten Bollinger Band. Did I mention the 50 DMA seems to be strong support as well? Tom Bollinger has some interesting things to say about different shoulder heights. Could be that the Indexes have all gotten their faces on a box of Wheaties and it's time to cash in?

  4. Agreed, along with volume to get complete confirmation, OBV ( on balance volume) I find works wonders in currency markets 🙂

Comments are closed.